civiccenter.jpg

Top 5 Reasons to Avoid Arbitration for Your Business Dispute

Apr 30, 2019

In our recent blog Top 5 Reasons to Consider Arbitration for your Business Dispute, we discussed some of the advantages of arbitrating your business dispute, and while the choice of forum will vary based on circumstance, just as there are reasons to arbitrate, there are reasons that it may not be right for your particular dispute. Below are some of the top reasons to consider alternatives, such as litigation, instead of arbitration.

1. Decisions are Generally Not Appealable.

In the US court systems, parties have a right to appeal. When parties agree to arbitrate a matter, they waive the opportunity to a trial by jury of peers, giving the power of judge and jury to an arbitrator or arbitrators. Generally speaking, arbitration decisions are legally binding, final and non-appealable.  A party dissatisfied with a decision will not have the same recourse to appeal as a party would in a trial court.

2.  Cost.

Arbitrations can be very expensive. Arbitrators in Denver bill by the hour with fees ranging between $250-$600 per hour.  Not only will you pay for the attorney’s and arbitrator’s time, but the arbitration association will also have administrative and filing fees as well as deposits. Arbitrations may also include panels of three and five-panel arbitrators, and their time spent reviewing documents or engaged in hearings will be particularly expensive. While it may advantageous over an opponent with a smaller budget, the costs associated with arbitration will add up quickly, and your budget should be carefully considered before deciding to go that route.

3. Limits on Discovery.

Many arbitrators place limits on discovery. Depending on the type of dispute, litigating a matter can offer parties the opportunity to gather more information about their opponent (or competitor) and use found information to encourage settlement negotiations or other resolution. Parties may also face restrictions on the number of depositions, interrogatories, and requests for production. Where arbitration may disfavor broad discovery that may seem unrelated to the dispute, litigation may delve deeper into issues through the discovery process.

4. Lack of Transparency.

Some businesses may not wish to have disputes publicly accessible, and arbitration is generally confidential rather than open to the public as the court system is. The argument can be made, however, that this privacy could increase the likelihood of bias. Having a matter in a public forum provides a different level of accountability than the privacy of arbitration. Arbitrators have been known to take a “split the difference” approach where they try to assuage both parties.

5.  More Informal Process.         

Arbitration is less formal than litigation, and while this may be advantageous in some situations, the lack of formality can also lead to further dispute over procedure and rules. An arbitrator can frame his or her own procedure with party input, but litigation is typically conducted under the particular jurisdiction’s Rules of Civil Procedure with strict enforcement by the judge.

This informality also means that the rules of evidence do not apply as they would in trial court. Arbitrators have sole discretion to determine evidence relevancy and may allow damaging evidence that might have been excluded in a more formal process such as a court trial.

 

mlmw_mark_MD.pngMallon Lonnquist Morris & Watrous is a  business, transactional and litigation law firmCraig T. Watrous is a Colorado litigator and partner at MLMW, based in Denver, Colorado. Craig regularly arbitrates business disputes and drafts and enforces arbitration provisions. Craig can be reached at cwatrous@mlmw-law.com.



Category: M&L Legal Posts

Category List


Tag List

Alternative Dispute Resolution (6)
Landlords (1)
Cherry Creek Chamber of Commerce (1)
Leases (7)
Spanish Legal Services (10)
Enforcing Non-Solicitation Agreement (1)
Landowners (1)
indemnifications (3)
Legal Updates (4)
Denver Business Journal (2)
Denver arbitration (1)
Colorado Courts (2)
Our Courts Colorado (1)
Certifiably Green Denver (1)
Mergers & Acquisitions (5)
subcontractor negotiations (2)
Phantom Stock (1)
Lease Negotiations (1)
Skiing Gear (1)
Legal Services (1)
Real Estate (6)
Colorado Hispanic Bar Association (1)
cyber security (3)
Non-Competition Agreements (12)
CO Ski and Snowboard Gear Recall (1)
Co-Ownership Agreement (1)
Employment (4)
Data Breach Settlement (1)
Snowboard Gear (1)
Spanish Business Law (9)
Non-Disclosure (1)
Denver Real Estate (1)
ABA (1)
Credit Card Data (1)
courts (1)
St. Anthony, Minnesota (1)
Colorado Judicial Institute (1)
Community (33)
Colorado attorney mentor (2)
Construction (6)
Colorado Employment (20)
Mediation (1)
Non-Solicitiation (1)
County Court (1)
LLC Law (2)
CO Attorney Mentoring Program (1)
News and Updates (13)
Overtime Wages (2)
Ethics (1)
cause for termination (1)
Colorado LLC (1)
Real Estate Law Firm (3)
Employment Law (1)
Colorado Lis Pendens (1)
Non-Solicitation (1)
Business Law (1)
Incentive Plans (1)
Non-Compete, Colorado non-compete restrictions, enforcing non-compete, protecting Colorado business (1)
Business Attorney (2)
Breach of Contract (1)
Colorado business disputes (1)
Property Surveys (1)
Reed Morris (1)
Wrongful Death Settlement (1)
Commercial Property (2)
CO Business Non-Solicitation Restrictions (1)
ABA Article (1)
Business Litigation (3)
Denver Sustainable Law Firm (1)
Non-Compete (2)
Stock Options (1)
Colorado Enforcement of Non-Compete (2)
Spanish Speaking Lawyers Committee (3)
Denver Business Law (1)
Denver Broncos (1)
Colorado Retail Leasing (1)
Colorado Wrongful Death (1)
Master Services Agreement (2)
Colorado Foundation for Water Education (1)
Commercial Real Estate (2)
Finance Law (2)
Denver Colorado Business Attorney (9)
Business (5)
Business Services (5)
Colorado Real Estate (11)
Resolutions (1)
Colorado Business (56)
Helmet Recall (1)
Data Breach (2)
Corporate Law (8)
Mechanic's Liens (1)
Labor (3)
(33)
Leasing Standard (1)
Cell Tower Leases (1)
Business Contracts (7)
Panelist (1)
American Bar Association (2)
Taxes (1)
attorney-client privilege (2)
Business Disputes (6)
Colorado Construction (1)
Trade Secrets (6)
Contracts (3)
Research (1)
Colorado at-will employment (1)
Colorado Spanish Legal Services (1)
Resolving Business Disputes (1)
Arbitration (5)
Construction Bond Claims (2)
ADR (2)
Construction Contracts (5)
Litigation (19)

Archive